East Coast Oysters

Blue Point $1.45


Malpeque $2..25

WellFleet $2.25


Little Neck OR

Top Neck Clams


West Coast Oysters

Kumamoto $2.85

Fanny Bay $2.50

Red, White + Blue

6 Blue Points, OR 6 Clams w/ a PBR, Chardonnay, OR Merlot


Shrimp Cocktail

1/4 LB Steamed Shrimp on Ice


Raw Sampler

6 Oysters, 2 Clams + 3 Shrimp



10 oz.  Bowl $9.00

Lobster Bisque

smooth creamy lobster based bisque

New England Clam Chowder

Creamy chowder, fresh clams, potatoes,

roasted garlic, bacon

Fish Market Soup

Slightly Spicy, Hearty Tomato, White Fish + Shrimp


Farmer's Scallop

Frisee, bacon, fingerling Potatoes, sunny side up egg, lemon & Olive Oil


Lobster Cobb

Lobster, Shrimp, Greens, Onion, avocado, bacon & Lemon herb dressing


Grilled Octopus

Arugula, baby potatoes, roasted peppers, capers, kalamata olives, dill vinaigrette



King Crab Legs

1/2 LB Steamed w/ Drawn Butter


Crab Cake

Lump Crab, tomatoes, chick peas, onions, cucumber, orange segments, fresh mint, old bay aioli


Wonton Tuna

Tuna, lemon zest, shallots, guacamole, chipotle aioli



Grilled or Fried, home-made marinara sauce


Twin Tartare

Tuna, salmon, & home-made potato chips


Scallop Ceviche

jalapeno, cilantro, tomato, onion, scallion, & lime


Lobster Mac + Cheese



Bay of Fundy Salmon


Catch of the Day


Tuna Steak


Whole Dorade Royale


Rosemary Roasted Chicken

Free Range half-chicken, rustic garlic mashed potatoes, rosemary jus


NY Sirloin Steak

Ottomanelli's 16oz, french fries & mixed greens



Catfish Sandwich

Blackened or Fried


Lobster Roll


Soft Shell Sandwich


Fish + Chips

British Style


Tuna Burger


Fried Oyster Roll


Steamed Mussels

Garlic lemon-butter, or marinara sauce


Bleecker Burger

Ottomanelli's famous blend


w/ Cheese or Bacon + $1.00


Down East Lobster Feast

1 1/4 Lb Whole Maine Lobster, Steamers, COrn + Fries


King Crab Legs

1 lb steamed w/ drawn butter + 2 sides


Pan-Roasted Red Snapper

W/ BBQ Shrimp + Cheddar Grits


Fisherman's Stew

Tomato Based w/ Clams, Shrimp, Scallopos, Mussels, Daily Catch + 1/2 Lobster


Crispy Skin Chilean Sea Bass

jalapeno Aioli, Roasted seasonal Vegetables


Surf + Turf

Ottomanelli's 16 oz Sirloin & half lobster, Salad


Scallops Dave's Way

Seared Diver Scallops w/ Sauteed Spinach


Horseradish Salmon

Smoked Salmon Crust w/ green beans & rustic mashed potatoes


Shrimp and Grits

Prawns, mushrooms, SAUTÉED spinach, grits 


Fish Tacos

Corn tortilla, coleslaw, crispy fish, pico de gallo


Whole Branzino

butterfly opened, Capers, Lemon, dill emulsion


Cristian's Paella

Shrimp, Clams, Mussels, Calamari + 1/2 Lobster Tail (30+ mins to prepare)


Maryland Blue Crabs

one dozen


Soft Shell Crabs

choice of 2 sides




Sauteed Spinach

Green Beans

Garlic Bread

Rustic Mashed  Potatoes

Cheddar Grits

Cole slaw

Lobster Whipped Potatoes $12.00

Sliced Tomato

Corn on the Cob

French Fries

Fish - 280 Bleecker Street, New York, NY 10014 - 212.727.2879